C. Both...;) Because people w/All Seasons think their cars grip so they drive what they think is reasonable and it turns out they were driving like it's a clear sunny day outside and speeding. And the guy with PP tires that is driving like driver A is an idiot because ice is on the road. Like many youtube videos...Don't drive like that guy.Very helpful. Show me I'm wrong. Who would you rather drive around:
a) Person with a PP Mustang with winter/all seasons driving appropriately for the conditions (below freezing, which always bring a potential for ice, as well)
b) Person with a PP mustang with summer tires driving the same way as person 'a'
I guess I'm the only one who sees the irony in buying sticky track tires because they're better for those conditions, but not buying winter/all season tires even though they are better for those conditions? You can't plan for every eventuality, but if you know it's consistently below freezing? And yeah, of course you don't redline it, but what if you have to brake quickly? Swerve to dodge debris or whatever? Your tires don't matter because you're not accelerating? That's the only time it matters?
Obviously you temper this for where you live - I live where we get snow, and I'm driving in it a LOT, so I have snow tires. If I lived where it was consistently cold, but no snow, I'd probably do performance all seasons for winter. If I lived where it only rarely dipped down cold enough to be of concern, then I'd probably be fine on the summer tires year round with the cautious driving. There is no black and white and to treat the argument as such is worthless.
No one ever answered my initial question though - why wouldn't you get the right tires for the situation? If you buy summer tires for the best traction in summer... why not get the right shoes for winter? Seems like a no brainer to me. And I get that cost is a factor, but as with all things car-wise, you have to pay to play. It's worth it to me to protect my investment, and only the initial cost is more since I'm not wearing out my summer tires during winter...
Some people (me) didn't get summer tires for best traction in summer, but because they came with the car.No one ever answered my initial question though - why wouldn't you get the right tires for the situation? If you buy summer tires for the best traction in summer... why not get the right shoes for winter? Seems like a no brainer to me. And I get that cost is a factor, but as with all things car-wise, you have to pay to play. It's worth it to me to protect my investment, and only the initial cost is more since I'm not wearing out my summer tires during winter...