Burkey
Well-Known Member
I’m really not sure. Is yes and no a suitable answer?Driving is a privilege in a society. It’s not required to work or survive. Going out into public is a right and making mask punishable by law makes people that don't wear them criminals. I do think that people should wear mask but capitalism can deal with this problem better than government. More and more major stores require mask. I expect all of them to require them soon Our governor mandated mask but the mandate has no teeth. It basically says please wear a mask but if you don’t there no punishment. Just shame from society.
Do you think not wearing a mask is a crime punishable with jail time?
I think we would both agree that fines hold different punitive value for different people. Eg. $1000 is a lot when you only have $1 but not much when you have several million dollars. Therefore, a financial penalty serves a very different function (if any whatsoever) depending on the disposable income/assets of the person in question.
Time on the other hand could be a far more equitable solution, providing at least some level of parity. A day is a day, no matter who you are. Even millionaires don’t typically laugh at the prospect of being detained where they might simply laugh at a “measly” fine.
There’s a tonne of issues in amongst all of it. Like most people, I’d prefer to see the proposal in full, it’s limitations, uses and outcomes before having any real “opinion” on its likely efficacy and the cost/benefit to the broader public.
As I assume you might know, Melbourne is now seeing a reasonably strong resurgence in infections. The state government has already put restrictions in place but at this stage, they don’t appear to be having any significant effect. Instead of waiting a few more weeks to see what happens, the state government has mandated masks for certain postcodes under certain icircumstances, broadly applying what you might call a “common sense” rule to it all. Yep, it’s kinda vague and I’d hate to be a cop trying to enforce it but it’s really fundamentally about changing peoples habits and mindset.
The state premier in his own words:
Sponsored