Was there a different issue? You are saying the quality is good why the 2nd one?I'm on my 2nd windshield, which is also a SoundScreen.
Quality seems good and all as far as taking a hit from rocks. Already 'caught' a few small ones and haven't had a crack yet, knock on wood.
However, in terms of quietness, I haven't noticed any major significant differences in noise levels from the stock windshield to this one.