I have had a 1997 Wrangler, a 2002 Wrangler and a 2009 Wrangler. All soft tops, all with half doors and plastic zip window uppers.
I loved my Jeeps. Never had any problems with any of them, and all were bought used.
The tops are a bit of a hassle, but not too bad when you get used to them...
'16 EcoBoost Premium Convertible. 95% or more city driving on very busy streets with lots of stop lights. I have averaged 20.1 for the last 1000 miles.
Easily do 27+ on the highway, when I get on it.