Pretty disappointed with new 17 GT buy

Freedom

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2016
Posts
1,010
Reaction score
289
Location
California
First Name
Mike
Vehicle(s)
'16 GT
My neighbor used to do third party QC engineering for one American luxury brand and another German brand. He relayed one story to me where one example from each brand had similar rattles coming from the top of the dash. The German brand decided to study and re-engineer its components to eliminate the rattle the right way, while the American brand's solution was to stack some felt strips underneath the suspected area of rattle until it went away. Both of these models directly competed with one another.

Appropriately enough, he owned one of the American branded cars he had done QC on...and swore he'd never buy from that brand again. That car was a total lemon. Ironically, he now works directly for the company that builds that brand.

I love American cars, and will always buy them, but I have to acknowledge that our cars are way behind our competitors in terms of fit and finish. Most of the creaks and rattles in my cars are from just sloppy workmanship. When I took delivery of my Mustang last year, I found hardware just laying in the passenger footwell. I never did find out if it was from something missing somewhere in the car, or if they were just extra bonus pieces, like extra fries in the bottom of the bag.

I adore my Mustang, but it has many of the same issues talked about on this forum; thin paint, weak glass, mystery creaks, inconsistent panel gaps. If the overall package wasn't good enough to overcome all of those issues, I'd be mad. But these are still great cars for the money, and I'm supporting my local industry as much as possible with my purchase.
Panel misalignment 100% dives me nuts. I’ve see worse on bmw but it’s no excuse for the shitty job on the mustang. They should at least do better for premium trim models, I’m not sure how the 18s are since it can go upwards of $50K now but the gt350 is still crap I think.
 
Last edited:

GreenS550

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2017
Posts
1,608
Reaction score
793
Location
Houghton, MI 49931
First Name
Bob
Vehicle(s)
2019 Mustang Bullitt K3107 Whipple 2018 Mustang GT Premium A10 Ruby Red
Boss Bandit my first new car in 1980 was a Fire Arrow. Built by Mitsubishi for Plymouth. It was warm white, black hood with a huge fire arrow on it. Mag wheels, 2.6L OHC engine witha 5 speed manual. I actually loved that car. It was the fastest car tested that year with a 1/4 mile of 17 seconds. My sister bought an Omni. Similar sized car. Slower. Every possible thing about that car broke, rattled, slow. Total junk. Then I ordered one of the fastest cars made in 1982, 1982 Mustang GT. I waited. It came in with thin paint which I spoke of earlier, intermittent power problem that the dealer couldn't figure out but I did. The real kicker was the day I picked it up, the 3rd time I closed the drivers door the arm rest pulled right off the door!
Once that stuff was fixed, the car was nearly perfect for the 40K miles I owned it. But, most folks would never have hung in there. I am paranoid about ordering a new Bullitt because of this. Just pick up a used one 6 mos old and check all the stuff out first. I simply don't trust the manufacturer. You just might get the "old maid".
 

Advertisement





 
213 - Auto Mafia Racing


Advertisement
Top